The Myths of Interchangeability and Autonomy: Reclaiming True Human Dignity
In today’s rapidly shifting cultural landscape, many Christians find themselves grappling with the far-reaching effects of the sexual revolution. As parents, mentors, and church leaders, we’re called to guide the next generation through these cultural shifts while staying true to God’s design. But how do we navigate these challenges when societal norms seem to drift further from biblical principles?
In this post, we’ll explore two fundamental lies of the sexual revolution: the idea that men and women are interchangeable and that autonomy is the source of our dignity. We’ll examine their impact on society and provide biblical wisdom to help you live out these truths and guide others through these turbulent waters.
The Myth of Interchangeability
The notion that men and women are interchangeable has evolved over time. As John Stonestreet explains:
Initially, in first-wave feminism, the idea that men and women were interchangeable was about men and women being interchangeable in rights. However, somewhere around second-wave feminism, this movement met the sexual revolution—many would say it was hijacked by it. In the second wave, the idea shifted from men and women being interchangeable in rights to men and women being interchangeable in roles.– John Stonestreet
This shift has led to confusion about biological realities and the concept of design. Today, we see this idea taken to extremes, with claims that biological sex is fluid or irrelevant. The consequences of denying the distinctiveness of men and women have impacted everything from personal identity to public policies.
Sign up to the Identity Project Newsletter
Get fresh wisdom and resources every week, straight to your inbox
The Myth of Autonomy as the Source of Dignity
The second lie of the sexual revolution is that autonomy is the source of our dignity. As society has moved away from a Christian understanding of human worth, it has attempted to ground dignity in autonomy instead. Stonestreet notes:
“Only in Christianity do you find this inherent source of dignity. So, dignity is an idea that specifically belongs to Christianity.”– John Stonestreet
When society rejects the Creator, it tries to redefine dignity by placing it in individual autonomy. This has led to a belief that a person’s worth is determined by their ability to choose and assert their own identity. But grounding human dignity in autonomy inevitably leads to exclusions and devaluation:
“Anytime we try to tether human dignity to anything other than the inherent value given by our Creator, somebody gets left out.”– John Stonestreet
This false belief has profound implications for how we view the vulnerable, including the unborn, elderly, and those with disabilities.
The Impact on Society
These ideas have led to:
- Confusion about gender roles and identity
- Violation of privacy in traditionally sex-segregated spaces
- Devaluation of human life, especially for the vulnerable
- A misunderstanding of true human dignity and worth
The consequences of grounding human dignity in autonomy and denying the distinctions between men and women have far-reaching effects on society, often leading to a diminished understanding of what it means to be human.
A Biblical Perspective
As Christians, we’re called to view humanity through the lens of God’s design. The Bible reminds us in Genesis 1:27 (NIV):
So God created mankind in his own image, in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them.– Genesis 1:27 (NIV)
This verse underscores both the equality and distinctiveness of men and women, as well as the source of our dignity—being created in God’s image.
Trusting Him, Shaping Me, Restoring Us
In light of these cultural challenges, how can we, as Christians, live out what it means to be truly human and reflect God’s design in a world that often denies it? The answer lies in embracing our identity in Christ and living out these foundational truths:
- Trust in God’s Design: God’s plan for humanity, including the distinctions between men and women, is rooted in His wisdom and love. Even when cultural messages seem overwhelming, trust that His design leads to true flourishing.
- Be Shaped by Christ: Allow Jesus’ teachings to shape your understanding of human dignity and worth. This means seeing ourselves and others as image-bearers of God, not defined by autonomy or societal roles.
- Participate in Restoration: By living out your faith authentically, you become a catalyst for restoring God’s vision of true human dignity in families and communities. Show the world the beauty of living according to God’s design.
Embodying Truth in Life and Words
As followers of Christ, we’re called not just to guide others, but to embody these truths in our own lives. Here are ways we can live out God’s design for human dignity and identity:
Live Out Your God-Given Identity: Embrace your identity as a man or woman created in God’s image. Let your life reflect the beauty of God’s design in relationships, work, and community.
Value Every Person: Treat everyone you encounter with dignity and respect, recognizing that their worth comes from being created in God’s image, not from their abilities, roles, or choices.
Cultivate Godly Relationships: In your marriages, friendships, and family life, demonstrate the complementary nature of male and female relationships as God designed them.
Speak Truth with Love: When discussions about gender, identity, or human worth arise, share biblical truth with gentleness and respect. Let your words be seasoned with grace, always pointing to the hope we have in Christ.
Model Dependence on God: Instead of promoting autonomy, demonstrate a joyful dependence on God. Show how true freedom comes from submitting to His design, not from asserting our own will.
Engage Culture Wisely: Be discerning about the media you consume and the ideas you embrace. Model for others how to think critically about cultural messages regarding identity and dignity.
Serve the Vulnerable: Actively care for those our culture often overlooks—the unborn, elderly, and those with disabilities. Show through your actions that every life has inherent worth.
By living out these principles, we become living testimonies to the truth of God’s design. Our lives will speak volumes, inviting others to discover the beauty and freedom found in embracing our true, God-given identity.
Are You Seeking to Live Out God’s Design?
The Identity Project offers biblically grounded resources to support you in reclaiming true human dignity and identity. Explore our video library and learning paths to deepen your understanding of God’s design for humanity and live out your identity as a powerful witness in today’s culture.
Start your free trial today at IdentityProject.tv and join us in embodying and restoring a truly human understanding of dignity and identity, one life at a time.
Looking for more like this?
Find more with a 7 day free trial to The Identity Project